Home

Community Education

PREVENTION BOOK

POPs Exposure Reduction

Dioxin Exposure

Dioxin Cancer Risk

Exhaust Cancer Risk

Stop Tar Sands

Cancer Risk Assessment

Dioxin Minimization

Major Dioxin Source

Open Burning Elimination

Research and URLs

Breast Cancer Prevention

Laws for Cancer Prevention

Institute of Medicine Report

Environmental Poetry

Petitioning the US FDA

TAKE ACTION

E Celebrations

CALENDAR

Cancer Action NY News

Cancer Action Radio

Reports

Report Updates

Cancer Detectives
 

Cancer Action NY inc.   


Breast Cancer Prevention

 

 

Fat Soluble Pollutant Carcinogens and Breast Cancer Risk

 

Donald L. Hassig, Director, Cancer Action NY

 

It has been recognized for a considerable number of years that an association exists between the consumption of animal fat foods and breast cancer (American Institute for Cancer Research, 1997; and Canadian Breast Cancer Initiative, 2001).  In 2003, the Journal of the National Cancer Institute published, “Premenopausal Fat Intake and Risk of Breast Cancer”.  The conclusion of the authors of this study was that consumption of animal fat during premenopausal years is associated with increased risk of breast cancer (Cho, 2003).  When the contamination of animal fats with dioxins, furans, dioxin-like PCBs, hexachlorobenzene, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which have been designated as probable or known human carcinogens, is taken into account, it becomes clear that part of the cancer risk imposed by fat consumption can be attributed to these contaminants.  Carcinogenic, fat-soluble pollutants reach elevated concentrations in breast tissue, thus completing the pathway whereby initiation and promotion of carcinogenesis can take place in the cells of the breast. 

 

An article titled, “Serum Dioxin Concentrations and Breast Cancer Risk in the Seveso Women’s Health Study”, has been published in Environmental Health Perspectives, the research journal of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (Warner, 2002).  Residents of the Seveso region of Italy were exposed to high levels of dioxins as the result of an explosion at a chemical factory.  A statistically significant association between dioxin levels in blood serum and breast cancer incidence was reported in this study.    

 

According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), over 90 percent of the American public’s exposure to dioxins comes from the consumption of foods containing milk fat, fish fat, tallow and other animal fats (US EPA, 2003).  Particulates, upon which are adsorbed dioxins and dioxin-like compounds, deposit from the polluted atmosphere onto animal feed crops such as pasture grass and corn.  Entry into the aquatic food chains occurs via contamination of surface waters.   Dioxins and other POPs accumulate in the animals’ fat tissue.  The average American’s dioxin exposure thus takes place at lower levels of food contamination than that which existed in the Seveso Women’s Health Study.  Nevertheless, the association demonstrated by this research should be taken into account for the purpose of determining a precautionary approach in so far as breast cancer prevention is concerned.  Women need to significantly lower their intake of animal fat foods as a breast cancer preventive measure.

 

Dioxins, furans, PCBs and hexachlorobenzene accumulate to ever increasing levels in the fat tissue of those who are regularly exposed.  The level, which these chemicals attain in the body, is a very significant health determinant.  Cancer risk is higher when elevated levels of cancer promoting dioxins and dioxin-like compounds are present.  The International Agency for Research on Cancer lists dioxins, dioxin-like furans and PCBs, and hexachlorobenzene as human carcinogens. 

 

Based upon an extensive body of scientific research, the US EPA has upgraded the cancer risk of dioxin exposure (US EPA, 2003).  Epidemiologic studies of several exposed groups:  workers who manufactured or applied dioxin contaminated pesticides, including pentachlorophenol, and 2,4,5-T; victims of an industrial accident in Seveso, Italy, which released kilogram amounts of dioxin; and US Air Force personnel engaged in Project Ranch Hand, the spraying of Agent Orange during the Vietnam War, demonstrate a linear relationship between dioxin exposure and increased cancer risk.  An oral dose slope factor of 1.0 x 10E-3 per pg dioxin TEQ/kg body weight/day has been derived from the US EPA risk model.  The average American consumes a quantity of animal fat sufficient to impose a dioxin exposure of 1 pg dioxin TEQ/kg bw/day  (see attached Table from US EPA dioxin reassessment).  This level of exposure is associated with a 1 in 1000 excess risk of developing cancer.  Doubling one’s intake of animal fat food results in a doubled cancer risk.  During the 1970s and 1980s, dioxin levels in animal fat foods were considerably higher than current levels.  Those who consumed animal fat produced over that time period have a significantly higher lifetime cancer risk.  Cancers associated with dioxin exposure include soft tissue sarcoma, lung cancer, non-Hodgkins lymphoma, breast cancer, and prostate cancer.  Lipophilic pollutants, such as dioxins, reach elevated concentrations in the fat tissue of the breast.  The exposures these cells receive from fat-soluble carcinogens are many orders of magnitude higher than those received by cell types other than fat cells.  Dioxins act to promote the development of tumors.  Promotion involves the selective acceleration of cellular growth and division for initiated cell lines.  The outcome of exposure to a promoting carcinogen is the more rapid development of a clinically detectable tumor, yielding earlier onset of the cancer. 

 

In utero and lactational exposure to 2,3,7,8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) has been associated with developmental abnormalities in the rat mammary gland (Fenton, 2002).  The permanent structural changes in mammary epithelium observed in this study may predispose rat offspring to breast cancer. 

 

The Long Island Breast Cancer Study reported an association between polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) exposure and increased incidence of breast cancer (Gammon, 2002).  Stationary sources, motor vehicles and open waste burning are major sources of PAH releases to air.  We are exposed to PAHs via two main routes, inhalation of polluted air, and consumption of foods that are contaminated with these fat-soluble pollutants.  Food consumption is the dominant exposure pathway.  An exposure rate of 3 milligrams/day has been estimated for the United States population.   

 

PAHs have been demonstrated to be genotoxic, forming DNA adducts in animal studies.  Oral doses are reported to result in elevated incidence of mammary tumors in animals.  The cancer potency of PAHs varies.  Dibenz[a,h]anthracene is the most potent PAH carcinogen.  Benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) ranks number two.  A quantitative cancer risk estimate has been developed for BaP.  This cancer potency factor is 7.3 per mg/kg bw/day. 

 

Based upon average diet, Americans are estimated to receive a dose of carcinogenic PAHs ranging from 1 to 5 micrograms/day.  Utilizing this dose and the BaP cancer potency factor, upper-bound estimates of the cancer risk of PAH exposure are between 1 in 10,000 and 5 in 10,000.

 

References:

 

American Institute for Cancer Research. “Food Nutrition and the Prevention of Cancer: a global perspective”, 1997; www.aicr.org/reportsummaicr.html

 

Canadian Breast Cancer Initiative. “Review of Lifestyle and Environmental Risk Factors for Breast Cancer”, The Canadian Breast Cancer Initiative Workshop on the Primary Prevention of Breast Cancer, Quebec City, Quebec, May, 2001

 

Cho, E, et al. “Premenopausal Fat Intake and Risk of Breast Cancer”; Journal of the National Cancer Institute, V 95: pp 1079-1085, July 2003

 

Fenton, S, et al. “Persistent Abnormalities in the Rat Mammary Gland following Gestational and Lactational Exposure to 2,3,7,8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD)”; Toxicological Sciences, 67, pp 63-74, 2002; http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11961217?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DiscoveryPanel.Pubmed_Discovery_RA&linkpos=1&log$=relatedarticles&logdbfrom=pubmed 

 

Gammon, M, et al. “Environmental Toxins and Breast Cancer on Long Island. I. Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon DNA Adducts”; Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, V 11:  pp 677-685, August 2002

 

US EPA. “Exposure and Human Health Reassessment of 2,3,7,8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-Dioxin (TCDD) and Related Compounds”, 2004; http://www.epa.gov/ncea/pdfs/dioxin/nas-review/ 

 

Warner, M, et al. “Serum Dioxin Concentrations and Breast Cancer Risk in the Seveso Women’s Health Study”; Environmental Health Perspectives, V 110: No 7, pp 625-628, July 2002; http://www.ehponline.org/members/2002/110p625-628warner/8warner-full.html

 

For further information:  Donald L. Hassig, Director, Cancer Action NY; P O Box 340, Colton, NY 13625; canceractionny@yahoo.com; www.canceractionny.org; 315 262 2456

 

 

****************************************************************************************

 

OPEN WASTE BURNING AS A MAJOR SOURCE OF DIOXIN RELEASES

Donald L. Hassig, Director, Cancer Action

The 1997 US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) report, "Evaluation of Emissions from the Open Burning of Household Waste in Barrels", provides a quantification of pollutants released by open waste fires. (Lemieux, 1997) The author indicates that burning the residential waste (paper, plastics, rubber, foam rubber and metal foils) of 1.5 families in barrels can release an amount of dioxins into the environment equal to that released by a municipal solid waste incinerator burning 200 tons per day. In follow-up test burns, the Agency has determined that open waste burning creates and releases dioxins over a considerable range of values due to the highly complex nature of combustion. (Gullett, 2000) Open waste fires are highly productive of dioxins due to the low temperature at which combustion occurs and limited oxygen availability. Sooty, smoldering fires are the fires that create dioxins most prodigiously. When polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is burned, dioxin emissions are increased.

Particulates, upon which are adsorbed dioxins and dioxin-like compounds, deposit from the polluted atmosphere onto animal feed crops such as pasture grass and corn. Entry into the aquatic food chains occurs via contamination of surface waters. Due to the highly persistent nature of these chemical pollutants, they bioaccumulate in the food chain.

As set forth in the EPA’s most recent dioxin inventory, open waste burning is considered to be the largest source of dioxin releases to the environment. (US EPA, 2005) It is estimated that approximately 20 million burning barrels are utilized for waste disposal in the United States.

A form of open burning that has been found to emit dioxins at greater rates than barrel burning is the burning of waste in open refuse heaps. Such fires are used for disposal of plastics and other waste materials on farms. These fires occur in close proximity to feed crops of cattle and other animals, and are thus likely to be particularly important in the contamination of the food supply.

Many states have banned open waste burning. Enforcement of these bans will be a necessary factor in the elimination of this polluting waste disposal practice. Public education on the adverse health effects of exposure to the emissions of open waste fires can also significantly contribute to open burning elimination.

References:

Gullett, B. K., P. Lemieux, C. Winterrowd, D. Winters. 2000. PCDD/F Emissions from Uncontrolled Domestic Waste Burning. Presented at Dioxin ’00, 20th International Symposium on Halogenated and Environmental Organic Pollutants & POPs, held Aug 13-17 at Monterey, CA. Corrected revision of short paper in Organohalogen Compounds 46: 193-196.

Lemieux, P. 1997. Evaluation of Emissions from the Open Burning of Household Waste in Barrels, Vol. 1. Technical Report, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Risk Management Research Laboratory, Research Triangle Park, NC. EPA/600/R-97-134a (NTIS PB98-127343).

US EPA. 2005. The Inventory of Sources and Environmental Releases of Dioxin-Like Compounds in the U.S.: the Year 2000 Update, March 2005 (EPA/600/p-03/002A), http://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/cfm/recordisplay.cfm?deid=132080

 

Cancer Action is now working to increase public awareness of the dioxin cancer risk factor by providing high school health instructors with the most recent science on this subject. Health instructors are required by New York State Education Law to educate students on breast cancer prevention (see section 804(3)(a) below) .

 

§ 804.  Health  education  regarding alcohol, drugs, tobacco abuse and
  the prevention and detection of certain cancers. 1.  All  schools  shall
  include,  as  an integral part of health education, instruction so as to
  discourage the misuse and abuse of alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs and
  promote attitudes and behavior that  enhance  health,  well  being,  and
  human dignity.
    2.  Instruction  regarding  alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs shall be
  included in the health education  provided  for  all  elementary  school
  pupils  and  shall  be  taught  by  the regular classroom teachers or by
  teachers certified to teach health education. Such instruction shall  be
  designed  according  to  the  needs  and  abilities  of  the  pupils  at
  successive grade levels with the purpose of developing desirable  health
  behavior,  attitudes, and knowledge as well as self-reliance and problem
  solving capacity.
    3.  Instruction  regarding  alcohol,  tobacco,  and  other  drugs,  in
  addition  to  continued health guidance in the junior high school grades
  and the senior high schools, shall be an integral  part  of  a  required
  health education course at each of these levels in the secondary schools
  curriculum.  Students  shall be required to demonstrate knowledge in the
  subject area through the use of a test, graded project or report, or any
  other means prescribed by  the  school  authorities  regarding  alcohol,
  drugs,  and tobacco. Any such course shall be taught by teachers holding
  a certificate to teach health. Related courses in the  secondary  school
  curriculum  shall  be  taught in a manner supportive of health education
  regarding alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs.  In  addition,  instruction
  regarding the dangers of driving while under the influence of alcohol or
  drugs shall be an integral part of a required health education course in
  the  senior  high  schools.  Such  instruction  shall be provided in all
  senior high schools whether or not these  schools  also  provide  driver
  education courses.
    3-a.  Instruction  regarding  methods  of  prevention and detection of
  certain cancers, including  but  not  limited  to  breast  cancer,  skin
  cancer,  testicular  cancer  and  other cancers where certain preventive
  measures have become generally accepted and  certain  detection  methods
  have  been  adopted  and  recommended  generally  to  the  public.  Such
  instruction shall be an integral part of  a  required  health  education
  course  at the senior high school level, in addition to continued health
  guidance in senior high schools. Any such  course  shall  be  taught  by
  teachers holding a certificate to teach health.
    4.  a.  The  commissioner  may  prescribe  in  regulations such health
  education courses which include instruction regarding alcohol,  tobacco,
  and other drugs as the commissioner may deem necessary and desirable for
  the  welfare  of pupils and the community. The contents may be varied to
  meet the needs of particular school districts, or portions thereof,  and
  need not be uniform throughout the state, provided, however, that school
  districts  shall  utilize  either  the  curriculum  for health education
  instruction regarding alcohol, tobacco and other drugs prescribed by the
  commissioner or a course approved by the commissioner in accordance with
  criteria established by the commissioner.
    b. The commissioner shall make  available  an  interpersonal  violence
  prevention  education  package  for  grades kindergarten through twelve,
  which package  may  consist  of  student  pamphlets,  parent  pamphlets,
  videotapes  and  other informative materials to be distributed to school
  districts, and shall encourage the use of such material as part  of  the
  health or other related curricula or programs.
    c.  The  regents  shall  review  the health curriculum requirements in
  existence on the effective date of this paragraph  for  the  purpose  of
  streamlining  such  curriculum  and  identifying any outdated components
  that may be eliminated or consolidated in order to ensure that  students
  have sufficient time and instruction to develop skills to address issues
  of violence prevention and mental health. To the extent appropriate, the
  regents shall modify the existing curriculum to provide greater focus on
  the  development  of  skills,  by  no later than middle school, that are
  needed  to  recognize,  cope  with  and  address   potentially   violent
  incidents,  including  an  understanding of student's roles in emergency
  situations, what to do when  confronted  with  another  student  who  is
  experiencing  a mental health problem, and other related skills designed
  to reduce the threat of violence in schools.
    5. School authorities shall provide the needed facilities,  time,  and
  place  for  the  instruction set forth herein and shall provide learning
  aids and curriculum resource materials  which  contribute  to  effective
  teaching  methods  and  learning  in health education regarding alcohol,
  tobacco, and other drugs.
    6. All pre-service training  programs  in  the  state  for  elementary
  teachers shall include adequate preparation regarding the instruction in
  alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs set forth herein, and no teacher shall
  be  licensed  except upon satisfactory demonstration of the competencies
  included in  the  institutional  proposals  approved  by  the  education
  department.
    7.  Nothing  contained  in this section shall be deemed to diminish or
  impair the duties of the commissioner with  respect  to  the  continuing
  program  for  critical  health  problems  established  by  chapter seven
  hundred eighty-seven of the laws  of  nineteen  hundred  sixty-seven  as
  amended. The commissioner shall coordinate actions taken under authority
  of  this  section  with the provisions of said chapter as they relate to
  health education in schools, inservice training and  training  programs,
  and curriculum or syllabus development regarding the deleterious effects
  resulting from the use, misuse, and abuse of alcohol, tobacco, and other
  drugs.

 

 

 

 

 





 
   

Create a Free Website